AR’s Spicy Honey Peanut Butter is the original hot honey peanut butter. It cherry-picks flavors from around the South: Virginia peanuts, wildflower and clover honeys, and habanero and ghost peppers. The ingredients blend together into a spread that is simultaneously rich, floral, sweet, and spicy.

Don’t let the spice deter you—you can do almost anything with this peanut butter: put it on toast, add it to your ramen, or toss some Thai noodles with it to elevate your dish with a little kick. You can even add it to desserts, such as drizzling over ice cream or incorporating it into cookies, for a sweet treat with plenty of depth.